MSI Radeon R9 270 Gaming OC and Sapphire Dual-X R9 270 OC Video Card Review

Jump To:

Temperature & Noise Testing

Temperatures are important to enthusiasts and gamers, so we took a bit of time and did some temperature testing on both Radeon R9 270 video cards

MSI Radeon R9 270 Gaming OC 2GB Idle Temperature:

r270-gaming-idle

Sapphire Dual-X R9 270 OC 2GB Idle Temperature:

sapphire-270-idle

 

The MSI Radeon R9 270 Gaming OC was found to idle at 25C with the fan running at right around 975 RPMs. The Sappphire Dual-X R9 270 OC wasn’t too far off that with an idle temp of 28C, but the fans were spinning at 1120 RPMs! It should be noted that the ambient room temperature was 22.0C (72F).

MSI Radeon R9 270 Gaming OC 2GB Gaming Temperature:

r270-gaming-load

Sapphire Dual-X R9 270 OC 2GB Gaming Temperature:

sapphire-270-gaming

The MSI Radeon R9 270 topped out at just 57C with the fans running at 1240 RPMs when gaming on it for an extended period of time.  The Sapphire Dual-X R9 270 hit 60C with the fans running at 2144 RPM.The clear winner when it comes to temperatures would have to be MSI as their card runs at a higher clock speed and runs cooler despite the fans spinning lower. Remember that MSI is using 95mm fan blades versus the 74mm found on the Sappphire Dual-X GPU cooler. 

After reviewing a bunch of the AMD Radeon R9 290 and R9 290X cards and seeing 94C load temperatures it is nice to once again see low temperatures!

temperature

We must have gotten a high leakage AMD Radeon R9 290 video card as our idle and load temperatures were pretty toasty. The AMD Radeon R9 290 has a temperature target setting of 95C by default and our reference card topped out at 94C when gaming and 41C when at idle. AMD said that the Radeon R9 290 and 290X should be about the same when it comes to temperature, but our Radeon R9 290 was running noticeably higher at idle. In fact, this is the highest idle temperature that we have seen in some time.

Sound Testing

We recently upgraded our sound meter to an Extech sound level meter with ±1.5dB accuracy that meets Type 2 standards. This meter ranges from 35dB to 90dB on the low measurement range, which is perfect for us as our test room usually averages around 36dB. We measure the sound level two inches above the corner of the motherboard with ‘A’ frequency weighting. The microphone wind cover is used to make sure no wind is blowing across the microphone, which would seriously throw off the data.

noise

The fan speeds and actual fan blade sizes greatly differ on these two Radeon R9 270 graphics cards, but we were shocked to find that the idle fan noise was pretty much identical at just over 40 dB.  When gaming though the MSI R9 270 Gaming fans only spun up to 1240RPM whereas the Sapphire Dual-X R9 270 OC fan blades went up to 2140 RPM.  You can easily hear this 900 RPM different and so our sound meter confirmed this by noting that the Sapphire card was over 4dB louder when gaming. Both have acceptable noise levels and are certainly quieter than your average card.

Print
Jump To:
  • Adino

    This is the latest comment,but whatever :P

    If I buy this card now,does they gave me any Battlefield 4?

    I will buy a MSI R9 270 (specifically the Gaming 2G BF4 version. Site : http://www.msi.com/product/vga/R9_270_GAMING_2G_BF4.html#overview)
    According to the site,they will gave me a free copy of BF4.My local store had one left in the stock,however I was unable to see the box.

    I was worried that I wouldn’t get any BF4,as I can buy better card from other brand BUT not getting any BF4.(Please take consideration that this is April 2014)

    What do you guys think,should I get this card or not?

  • realdeal

    This review is very bias toward msi. Msi is not that better like it was represented in this review. Especially overclocking part, Ask yourself why they did not tested sapphire at gpu 1050, mem 1500, and power +20 ??? As you can see memory on sapphire can easily go to 1625, that means that is it BETTER MEMORY CHIP, at that matter most (beside GPU chip).

    This review is FAKE.

    • Matti Alexander Christensen

      most likely not, and no, they both use hynix memory chips, but sapphire uses better vrm. however the hynix memory seems to have a wall at 1500 mhz, meaning that going above that will decrease performance in many cases.
      so what we are seing is that the sapphire card can clock just as high, while using less power, and even go beyond the limits of the memory chips, even though its inefficient.

    • Ansau

      Your arguments are the fake:
      1- What we see is SOFTWARE LIMITATION. This is what you can reach with Catalyst. With MSI Afterburner or EVGA Precision X numbers could be higher.
      2- Yes, with Catalist you can push Sapphire much higher, but they also said they let to 1050MHz cause higher was unstable. And that means they reached its cap. We don’t know how much MSI can be pushed, but it’s easy to be higher than Sapphire (normally, higher base clocks allows higher OC clocks).
      3- Better clocks setting doesn’t mean better performance. 3DMark punctuations show you. MSI=5646, Sapphire=5467. MSI performs better with the same GPU clock and slightly slower memory clock.

      That doesn’t mean Sapphire is a bad choice, they have done a good job, just maybe MSI has done a killer.

      PD: Also, there’s a MSI promotion with BF4 for just +10€.

  • Nerdrage

    Great review. Sapphire need to offer more if they want to better.